Teacher Leaders: Demonstrating the Ethic of the Profession
Genre
Thesis/DissertationDate
2009Author
Renehan, Cynthia LeeAdvisor
Shapiro, Joan PolinerCommittee member
Caldwell, Corrinne A.Schifter, Catherine
DuCette, Joseph P.
Partlow, Michelle Chaplin, 1941-
Department
Educational AdministrationSubject
Education, AdministrationClashes Between Codes
Codes of Ethics
Ethic of the Profession
Ethical Decision-making
Ethical Paradigms
Teacher Leadership
Permanent link to this record
http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12613/2229Metadata
Show full item recordDOI
http://dx.doi.org/10.34944/dspace/2211Abstract
This case study investigated the ethic of the profession, one of the four ethical frameworks used for ethical decision-making in education. Typically, this line of research is applied to school administrators; however, this investigation extended this research to teacher leaders by examining their daily practice. Out of a pool of thirty-six respondents, nine teachers were chosen to participate in the study. These teacher leaders were employed in urban, exurban, and suburban school districts, with experience levels varying from three to thirty-three years. Participants were required to complete the following: the Self-Assessment to Assess Readiness for Leadership, creation of personal code of ethics, and the creation of professional code of ethics. An in-depth interview to discuss the codes, and clashes between codes was conducted, as well as a second interview to address an ethical dilemma identified by the participants. Categorical analysis was used to recognize recurring themes. A conceptual model of the decision-making process was developed to explain the phenomena observed in these data. In addition, recurring themes were identified through analysis of the interview data. Themes included a prevailing concern for fairness, student welfare, educational equality, safety, and student discipline. When responding to critical events that triggered ethical dilemmas, these participants habitually used their personal and professional codes of ethics to determine a course of action. Participants exhibited a sophisticated decision-making approach which moved participants past the reliance on one ethical frame of justice, critique, or care, into the use of multiple paradigms to solve ethical dilemmas. In the final analyses, the ethic of the profession was demonstrated by these nine teacher leaders through reflection and reliance on personal and professional codes of ethics, and by placing students at the center of the ethical decision-making process.ADA compliance
For Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accommodation, including help with reading this content, please contact scholarshare@temple.eduCollections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Engaging the Disengaged: an Assessment of the Medical Ethics Curriculum and Suggestions for its ImprovementThe medical ethics curriculum is an important part of medical education as it helps foster students to become virtuous and compassionate caretakers. The format of the curriculum is intended to expose students to ethical and moral issues early in their careers and allow them to apply their knowledge in clinical situations. However, the implementation of the curriculum is incredibly varied and fraught with challenges. This thesis explores the challenges of the current format of the medical ethics curriculum and the repercussions that will extend throughout medical school and moving into residency and beyond. It will additionally delve into potential solutions that, if implemented conscientiously, can encourage more engaged and thoughtful discussions in the classroom and the clinical setting. It is the ultimate hope that such interventions will result in students’ increased moral development and shape these future physicians into better caretakers, colleagues, and leaders.
-
THE ETHICS OF CARE AND GLOBAL SOCIO-EMOTIONAL COMMONS: AMELIORATING AND DISSOLVING THE EFFECTS OF GLOBAL CARE CHAINSIn recent decades, care ethics has become more visible in discussions of contemporary moral problems; however, longstanding ethical theories such as deontology and utilitarianism remain prominent in discussing controversial contemporary issues. I show the relevance of care ethics in discussions of globalization, especially regarding care ethics's applicability to the problem of "global care chains." Global care chains form when a person from a developing nation, usually a female, emigrates to serve as a fulltime nanny or housekeeper for a middle or upper class household. Her remittances pay for another care worker to replace her at home during her absence. This chain of caring labor extends across oceans and involves multiple households and various intricate webs of relationship. Care chains are problematic for three reasons. First, immigrant care workers find themselves particularly vulnerable to manipulation and abuse at the hands of their wealthy employers: Generally, labor laws in most countries do not apply to workers in private households. Second, the consistent migration of female care workers from poorer to wealthier countries eventually damages the socio-emotional commons in these workers' home communities. Third, care chains maintain the global illusion that women have achieved genuine equality with men: Because the gendered division of labor persists in the private and public sphere along with the masculine career model, women generally still find themselves burdened with the second-shift of caring labor in their homes. In response, I propose the use of "caring contracts" to address these conflicts. First, the caring contract shows how care ethics's feminist priorities can work in conjunction with the liberally derived concept of contractual arrangements between seemingly distant parties. Second, caring contracts prohibit the abuse of immigrant care workers while motivating a global conversation regarding the patriarchal and masculinist norms that have encouraged women's reliance on care chains. Privileged men and women will have to reconsider the true value of care work and understand why all capable individuals should participate in its completion. This dialogue would have to include revising global economic polices that have forced women in developing countries to emigrate for employment opportunities.
-
The Ethical Imperative of Narrative Care: The Necessity of Applying Narrative Skills to Clinical & Bioethical PracticeMedicine and bioethics today are though as fields of pure logic, reasoning, and science, with physicians and ethicists trained to approach patients with an attitude of detatched rationality. In reality, neither medical care nor ethics can be practiced well without an acknowledgement for their deeply emotional, relational, and narrative qualities. Medical care and bioethics must both be practiced through a narrative lense in order to truly meet the humanity of both patients and practitioners. There are practical methods to integrate narrative skills into clinical practice, as well as tangible benefits to doing so. Practially, this is performed through narrative medicine: an approach to medical care that recognizes the stories as a critical component to healthcare; as well as narrative ethics: an awareness of the essential role of narrative in moral understanding. Using narrative as a tool to understanding illness and moral grounds the more abstract and universal aspects of both in practical, individual reality. There are many practical aspects of narratives when applied to bioethics, such as aquiring narrative skills, what happens when stories are shared, recognizing how narratives are built, how they convey knowledge, organize life, and provide meaning. Illness creates an isolation – for both patient and practitioner – and stories allow each to express their experience and be supported though the stories of others. Stories help brigdge the gap in experiences of illness between practioner and patient while helping pracitioners to maintin their empathy in the face of continual suffering. Narrative skills are also useful for practioners to bring awareness to the power dynamics that influence patient stories, such as the power of practitioner as co-creator, whose voice is given credibility, external and internal influences on a story, who determines the meaning of a story, and how the patient is characterized within the story. Narrative permeates every aspect of human life, including medical and ethical situations, and approaching both through a narrative lens is imperative for the development of true understanding, empathy, and compassion. Cultivating a narrative framework towards illness allows both practioners and patients to be cared for while also caring for the other, thus creating deep, meaningful connections.
