EFFECTS OF RACIALIZED TRACKING ON RACIAL GAPS IN SCIENCE SELF-EFFICACY, IDENTITY, ENGAGEMENT, AND ASPIRATIONS: CONNECTION TO SCIENCE AND SCHOOL SEGREGATION
Genre
Thesis/DissertationDate
2015Author
Chang, Briana L.Advisor
Jordan, Will J.Committee member
Cromley, JenniferKlugman, Joshua
Lombardi, Doug
Thurman, S. Kenneth
Department
Urban EducationSubject
EducationEducation, Sociology of
Education, Secondary
Racialized Tracking
Science Engagement
Science Identity
Science Self-efficacy
Segregation
Stem Career Aspirations
Permanent link to this record
http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12613/2681Metadata
Show full item recordDOI
http://dx.doi.org/10.34944/dspace/2663Abstract
Given the concentration of economic growth and power in science fields and the current levels of racial stratification in schooling, this study examined (1) the effects of race on students’ connectedness to science and career aspirations, (2) the extent to which these effects were moderated by school racial composition and racialized tracking, and (3) the differences in modeling effects using separate variables for race and gender (i.e., White, Black, Hispanic, female) versus race/gender (e.g., White female, Black male, etc.). Using the lens of racial formation theory, this study situated access to science knowledge as a racial project, conferring and denying access to resources along racial lines. Reviews of the literature on science self-efficacy, identity, engagement, and career aspirations revealed an under-emphasis on school institutional factors, such as racial composition and racialized tracking (which are important in sociological literature), as shaping student outcomes. The study analyzed data from the nationally representative High School Longitudinal Study that surveyed students in 2009 during their freshman year in high school and again in 2012 during most students’ junior year (n = 6,998). Affective ratings (in self-efficacy, identity, engagement) and career aspirations for students measured in 2012 were examined as dependent variables and a variable for racialized tracking was estimated given schools’ placement of students in advanced science coursework in 2012. Although school racial composition was not found to moderate race on outcome effects, primary analyses demonstrated that the presence of racialized tracking in the students’ schools did moderate these effects. Overall these results suggested that the student subgroups most often at a disadvantage compared to White students for the science outcomes studied were Hispanic males and females; Black students’ ratings and aspirations were largely on par or exceeded those of their White counterparts. In addition, results indicated that racialized tracking served to exacerbate gaps for Hispanic students and may also diminish career aspirations for Black students. Finally, while examining effects by race/gender did provide some additional insight and nuance in the interpretation of these results, there were clear instances where these more detailed analyses were not needed or may have obscured results that were clearer when aggregated by race. Given these results, implications for policy, practice, and future research are discussed.ADA compliance
For Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accommodation, including help with reading this content, please contact scholarshare@temple.eduCollections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Developing a Leisure Meanings Gained & Outcomes Scale (LMGOS) and Exploring Associations of Leisure Meanings to Leisure Time Physical Activity (LTPA) Adherence among Adults with Type 2 Diabetes (T2D)It is estimated that 61% of people with Type 2 Diabetes (T2D) don't engage in any form of leisure time physical activity (LTPA) (Morrato, Hill, Wyatt, Ghushchyan, & Sullivan, 2007). One of the primary interventions to manage T2D is regular engagement in Leisure Time Physical Activity (LTPA) (Sigal, Kenny, Wasserman, Castaneda-Sceppa, & White, 2006). Many studies have tried to increase the frequency of LTPA in this population with little success (e.g., Williams, Bezner, Chesbro, & Leavitt, 2005). A new innovative approach to increasing engagement in LTPA is needed. Feelings of enjoyment have been found to correlate with adherence to LTPA (e.g., Williams, Papandonatos, Napolitano, Lewis, Whiteley, & Marcus, 2006) and theorized to be an outcome of experiencing something that is personally meaningful (Snyder & Lopez, 2002). It has also been found that "participation in leisure...continues when the experiences and/or the activity are meaningful to the individual" (Ragheb, 1996, p. 247). Thus, exploration of personal meanings that are valued and experienced within LTPA may be a key approach to effectively increasing LTPA. A content-analysis of the literature yielded the identification of five leisure meanings and three outcomes that are derived within and/or from leisure activity engagement. A new scale, the Leisure Meanings Gained and Outcomes Scale (LMGOS), was developed to reflect the findings. It was confirmed by an expert panel for face and content validity and then administered to Temple University students (n = 163). Exploratory factor analyses provided evidence for construct validity and reliability and led to further refinement. The refined LMGOS was given to adults with T2D (n = 26). The results showed significant correlations between specific leisure meanings gained and LTPA engagement, as well as between outcomes of meanings gained and LTPA engagement. The implications of the study include demonstrating: (a) the utility of a theoretically and psychometrically sound measure of the meanings gained and its outcomes via leisure (i.e., LMGOS), (b) the need for acknowledging meaning-oriented experiential and emotional properties of LTPA from a more holistic and humanistic perspective, and (c) the importance of meaning-seeking or meaning-making through leisure as a key facilitator to active living and health promotion for people including individuals with T2D.
-
Risk Acceptance and Contentious Politics: An Understanding of Protest ActivityWhat are the individual characteristics which motivate individuals to participate in contentious politics? This dissertation claims that risk acceptance as a psychological concept allows us to understand the individual predispositions that impact participation in protest activity. This dissertation project is significant to the field of political science in that it theorizes about the characteristics that make individuals risk acceptant and utilizes risk acceptance in the study of contentious politics, which has not been done before. I import claims from social psychology to highlight how lack of completion of several life cycle markers-which I name risk weights, such as marriage, parental status, and educational attainment amongst others-make individuals more risk acceptant. Once these risk weights are mapped onto risk, it allows one to determine and explain when protest activity is likely to occur. My dissertation uses a mixed-method approach to examine the relationship between risk acceptance and contentious politics. It is divided into the following components: one measure for risk acceptance, two online experiments, and field interviews in Chile. There are two main claims that this project posts: The first is that high levels of risk acceptance correspond with higher likelihood of participation in different forms of contentious political events, with case study work focusing on protest activity in Latin America. The second claim is that risk acceptance is a function of risk weights. The more risk weights that an individual has, the less likely they are to participate in contentious politics. Conversely, the fewer risk weights that an individual has, the more likely they are to participate in contentious political action. One of the important contributions of my work is that it treats risk acceptance as a purely psychological factor, one that is stable and only changes in accordance with risk weights, but that is not impacted by the context in which individuals are embedded. This means that the decision to participate or not participate in contentious political action is a function of the interaction between risk acceptance and some other contextual factors which are beyond the scope of my present research. This dissertation aims to identify the likelihood of participation for any individual. Social psychology has been underutilized in the study of contentious politics and can provide insights into why individuals self-select into these movements. In the context of worldwide mass mobilization, this allows us to understand the underlying individual psychological predispositions that lead to mass mobilizations and waves of mobilizations. Examining how these psychological mechanisms manifest themselves into various forms of contentious politics has important potential applications for the study of contentious politics.
-
Network Update and Service Chain Management in Software Defined NetworksSoftware Defined Networking (SDN) emerged in recent years to fundamentally change how we design, build and manage networks. To maximize the network utilization, its control plane needs to frequently update the data plane via flow migration as the network conditions change dynamically, which is known as network update. Network Function Virtualization (NFV) addresses the problems of traditional expensive hardware appliances by leveraging virtualization technology to implement network functions in software modules (middleboxes). These software modules, also called Virtual Network Functions (VNFs), are provisioned most commonly in modern networks to demonstrate their increasing importance. The technical combination of SDN and NFV enables network service providers to pick service locations from multiple available servers and maneuvers traffic through appropriate VNFs, which is known as VNF deployment. A service chain consists of multiple chained VNFs in some order. VNFs are executed on virtualization platforms, which makes them more prone to error compared with dedicated hardware. As a result, one important issue of service chain is its reliability, meaning that each type of VNF in a service chain acts properly on its function, which is known as service chain resilience. This dissertation lists our research on the above three mentioned topics in order to improve the network performance. Details are as follows: 1. Network Update: SDNs always need to migrate flows to update the network configuration for a better system performance. However, the existing literature does not take flow path overlapping information into consideration when flows’ routes are re-allocated. Consequently, congestion happens, resulting in deadlocks among flows and link resources, which will block the update process and cause severe packet loss. We propose multiple solutions with various kinds of leisure resources in the network. 2. VNF Deployment: We focus on the VNF deployment problem with different settings and constraints, including: (1) network topology; (2) vertex capacity constraint; (3) traffic-changing effect; (4) heterogeneous or homogeneous model for one VNF kind; (5) dependency relations between VNFs. We efficiently deploy VNF instances and at the same time make sure that the processing requirement of all flows are satisfied. 3. Resilient Service Chain Management: One effective way of ensuring VNF robustness is to provision redundancy in the form of deploying backup instances besides active ones. In order to guarantee the service chain reliability, we consider both the server resource allocation and the VNF backup assignment. We aim at minimizing the total cost in terms of transmission delay and rule changes.
