Mathematics Confidence in an Urban High-School: Black students' perception of mathematics education
Genre
Thesis/DissertationDate
2017Author
Saintine, ThierryAdvisor
Jordan, Will J.Committee member
Cucchiara, Maia BloomfieldNewton, Kristie Jones, 1973-
Brandt, Carol B.
Department
Urban EducationPermanent link to this record
http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12613/2291Metadata
Show full item recordDOI
http://dx.doi.org/10.34944/dspace/2273Abstract
This was an investigation of students’ mathematics confidence and how it is shaped by their accumulated experiences in mathematics education, and informs their view of the purpose of mathematics in their current and envisioned lives. There is no shortage of studies on black students’ poor performance in mathematics education and its seeming persistence in spite of reform initiatives and policy changes. Conversely, there is a dearth of studies in the field on high achieving black students and the construction of their mathematics identities. Some scholars have argued that the plenitude of data on the failure of black students in mathematics education has contributed to mainstream beliefs of a racial hierarchy of mathematics ability in America. This perception has not only shaped attitudes and behaviors of educational scholars, policymakers, practitioners, but it has contributed to the alienation of many students from the community of “doers of mathematics.” In an effort to combat the pervasiveness of race-based beliefs of math ability, some researchers in the field of mathematics have advocated for the need to refocus research on better understanding students’ mathematics identity and its relationship to their performance. In light of this, this study, using ethnographic methods, examined the mathematics confidence—a subset of mathematics identity—of a group of seniors enrolled in honor’s pre-calculus at an under resourced urban comprehensive high school. Data collected and analyzed for this study showed that participants, in spite of a history of mostly success in math and despite being socialized to view the classroom as opportunity to challenge disparaging views of African Americans, refused to seek or claim membership to the community of math people. This study provides new insights into black students’ perception of and sense of belongingness to mathematics, and its potential impact on their academic and economic prospects.ADA compliance
For Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accommodation, including help with reading this content, please contact scholarshare@temple.eduCollections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
English Language Learners Learn from Worked Example Comparison in AlgebraThis project is aimed at generating new knowledge and improving our understanding of how Modified for Language Support-Worked Example Pairs (MLS-WEPs) contribute to effective mathematics learning and teaching in an ESOL (English to Speakers of Other Languages) context. The current study investigated a novel instructional approach to help English Language Learners (ELLs) develop better understanding in mathematical reasoning, problem solving, and literacy skills (listening, reading, writing, and speaking) while they are still developing their English language proficiency. The current study followed a wait-list control design, with both the treatment and control groups receiving intervention materials. The intervention materials were administered multiple times with different topics (units) throughout the study. The lessons were audio-recorded when the selected topics were taught. Pretest and posttest were given each time when the selected topics were taught. The data analysis for this study included both qualitative and quantitative analyses. The present study revealed the following results: (1) MLS-WEPs not only enhanced ELLs’ ability to solve mathematical problems, but also improved their written explanation skills and enabled them to transfer such skills to different mathematical concepts; (2) when controlling ELLs’ prior knowledge, the effectiveness of the MLS-WEPs intervention did not vary by their English language proficiency; (3) the MLS-WEPs intervention materials facilitated teachers to provide ELLs with more opportunities to read, write, and speak in mathematics and enabled teachers to ask more and deeper questions. However, worked example comparisons did not appear to motivate the participant teachers to promote equitable participation in mathematics classrooms. These findings provide direct empirical support for the need to reform mathematics teaching and learning in the ESOL context.
-
Developing A Student Heuristic For The Use And Selection Of Mathematics Instructional Videos Using the Didactic Contract and ResponsibilitiesThis study investigated the ways in which college algebra students watch mathematics instructional videos with the goal of answering the following research questions: (1) How are student responsibility frames similar or different among students within a particular video? (2) How do the various video design principles support or constrain the uses of particular responsibility frames? This research was guided by the cognitive theory of multimedia design and the theory of didactic situations. The cognitive theory of multimedia design outlined principles for video creation and design that could impact student learning from video watching. The theory of didactic situations defined implicit teacher and student responsibilities within the context of the face-to-face mathematics classroom and was applied in this study to students watching mathematics instructional videos. Participants were recruited from five college algebra classes at a university in the northeastern United States and were asked to attend two semi-structured interviews. During the first interview, participants were pretested to determine their prior knowledge about how to solve quadratic functions and to measure their mathematics-related beliefs. During the second interview, participants watched three different videos about solving quadratic equations by completing the square and were asked questions about the mathematics that they viewed in the videos. Transcriptions of audio recordings of these interviews were coded thematically using categories previously identified by the didactic contract for the face-to-face classroom and expanding the types of student responsibilities identified specifically for video watching as needed. This study found that participants, regardless of overall prior knowledge or mathematics-related beliefs, but who had prior knowledge of completing the square, held a responsibility to use the specific set of steps they were taught by their teacher to solve problems. Additionally, participants at some levels of prior knowledge expressed a responsibility to not watch videos that showed a visual representation of the mathematics. Findings also suggested a student heuristic for the selection and use of mathematics instructional videos that may be useful to both mathematics teachers and video creators.
-
Promoting Preservice Teachers' Mathematics Identity ExplorationDespite the effort of teacher education programs, early childhood, and elementary preservice teachers often fear mathematics, have high mathematics anxiety, hold negative self-perceptions in relation to mathematics, find mathematics irrelevant, and have low mathematics achievement. The aim of this study was to implement and investigate the influence of an identity exploration intervention on preservice teachers’ identities in mathematics during a required mathematics content course of a teacher education program to provide insight into the patterns of change in identity and motivation towards mathematics. Twenty-four preservice teachers focusing on either early childhood education or non-mathematics secondary education were included in this study from a college algebra course specifically designed for education majors. Data collection included surveys, identity-related worksheets, identity exploration tasks, reflective writing assignments, interviews, and observations. Data was analyzed using the Dynamics Systems Model of Role-Identity and the principles for promoting identity exploration (Kaplan, 2014). This model highlights the interaction between self-perceptions, beliefs, purposes and goals, and actions. Analysis led to identification of patterns of change in student role identities and themes across cases that highlight the differences in change between the early childhood participants and secondary education participants, the influence of initial identity, and the impact of perceived relevance on identity exploration. This study contributes to the understanding of identity exploration in a mathematical setting and discusses future directions of research in promotion of identity exploration in preservice teachers.
