Characterizing the Immobile Region of the Hyporheic Zone through the use of Hydrologic and Geophysical Techniques at Crabby Creek, PA, USA

Abstract

At Crabby Creek, an urbanized watershed in northeast Chester County, Pennsylvania, an NaCl tracer test was conducted in 2010 to assess changes in hyporheic flow from a 2009 tracer test around the same stream restoration J-Hook. This project compares the 2009 and 2010 tracer test breakthrough curves and geophysical time-lapse resistivity surveys. This project also compares elevation cross sections and tile probing from 2009 and 2010, both measured upstream and downstream from the J-Hook. To confirm areas of lingering tracer seen in the time-lapse resistivity profiles, sediment cores using the freeze core method were taken to measure pore water for tracer. This project also measured diurnal temperature flux through the streambed at several locations along the sample site to model vertical water and heat flux. The breakthrough graphs constructed from the conductivity of the well water samples shows similar hyporheic flow characteristics from 2009 to 2010. The time-lapse resistivity profiles show an area of lingering tracer upstream from the J-Hook in 2010 that is similar in shape and location to an area upstream from the J-Hook in the 2009 profiles. However, an area of lingering tracer downstream from the J-Hook present in 2009 as a round feature on the profile is now a thin linear feature. The freeze cores show tracer present in the pore water after the end of the tracer injection in the stream sediment, confirming areas of lingering tracer seen in the time-lapse resistivity profiles. The grain size analysis of the freeze cores and the comparison to the 2009 cores taken at Crabby Creek show similar grain size distribution upstream from the J-Hook. Downstream from the J-Hook the grain size analysis shows a redistribution of sediment. Upstream from the J-Hook the tile probe shows both shallower and deeper bedrock, a redistribution of sediment but no net erosion. Downstream from the restoration structure, however, the tile probe data show a sediment loss of 20 cm. Elevation cross section surveys from 2009 and 2010 confirm what the tile probing found, a loss of sediment downstream but not upstream from the J-Hook. Temperature modeling of heat flux through the sediment shows that the diurnal temperature distribution can be accounted for without vertical flux. Thus, the immobile regions upstream and downstream from the J-Hook seem to be related to sediment distribution rather than hydrologic gradient differences. The significance of this study shows the need to use multiple techniques to characterize the immobile zone as a part of hyporheic flow. The immobile zone is an important area of chemical reactions in the streambed. At Crabby Creek the central J-Hook inhibits net erosion patterns upstream from the structure, allowing for the continued presence of an immobile zone. Downstream from the central J-Hook the erosion of the streambed sediment led to a decrease in size and location of the immobile zone. The disturbance of sediment around restoration structures influences the development of a healthy hyporheic flow and needs to be studied for future restoration of impaired streams and riparian corridors.